1

Is it possible to determine a person's zodiac sign without knowing date of birth?

First problem with this question, it doesn't actually have a claim. It links to an article that has 8 different claims. So this question should be edited to include the actual claim or claims that it is making.

Now, lets look at the 8 claims:

  1. Based on personality. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on personality. Problem: Should be closed as a duplicate
  2. Based on looks. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on appearance. Problem: Should be closed as a duplicate
  3. Learn about astrological masculinity/femininity. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on personality. Problem: Should be closed as a duplicate
  4. Become familiar with the elements. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on appearance and personality by correlation with certain elements. Problem: Off topic, this is wacky science and doesn't need to be disproved
  5. Observe their behaviour. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on personality. Problem: Should be closed as a duplicate
  6. Pay attention to the age of the person's sign. Claim: You can tell a person's zodiac sign based on personality. Problem: Should be closed as a duplicate
  7. Ask the person's birthday and use Google. Problem: Fact based, not a claim
  8. Ask them

The main claim seems to be that you can tell a person's zodiac sign based on their appearance or personality, which suggests that they have been influenced by the planets. Which is astrology, which has already been asked.

Can we please close it as a duplicate, it is poorly written and doesn't bring anything else to the table.

1

I've closed the question, and requested the OP clarify which claim they are skeptical about.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .