For example, "What's the real reason Bush attack Iraq?" or "Why people are religious?


If a politician makes a specific claim that is in the realm of science? Yes.

If it is about the "real" motivations of a person? No, that can't be meaningfully answered.

The question "Why are people religious?" is, as it stands, off-topic. There is no claim, it is just a general question. Issue discussed here.

The basic template isn't that hard: Find someone notable, or lots of people, who said something you suspect might be wrong, and quote them, with a link back to where they said it. There are variations to that template, but it is a pretty good start.

Common mistakes:

  • Not quoting anyone.
  • Making up your own quote.
  • Quoting someone you are sure is right.
  • Quoting someone who is saying something unfalsifiable.
  • Quoting someone who gives lots of evidence to support their statement, unless you have some reason to doubt it.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .