0

This question: Does drinking water after eating watermelon cause cholera? has been closed by you. I am not aware of the rules and policies of this website--neither I want to know them. So please tell me how should I edit my question so as it will be appropriate for this website. I would also appreciate if someone else edit my question in such a way that it could be reopened.

My main question is
"What are the experiments done on the human body that falsify these(harmful effects of drinking water after eating water melon) myths?"

All the remaining portion can be deleted/edited in any way. If my question cannot be reopened in any way then please delete my question and my account too. I am not interesting in any kind of discussion of your policies.

| |
  • "neither I want to know them" - the StackExcahnge is designed to me more than a website, it's a community. Embarking on participation with the "neither I want to know them" attitude may not be the most advisable approach. – user5341 Sep 17 '14 at 17:25
3

Your question currently contains a large number of question following the form: "Does eating X and then drinking Y cause Z?" where X, Y & Z are:

  1. watermelon, water, trees to grow in your stomach
  2. fish only - no other meal, water, ???
  3. fish, water or milk, weakening of digestion system
  4. fish, water or milk, fever
  5. fish, water or milk, cold
  6. fish, water or milk, cholera
  7. fish, water or milk, vitiligo
  8. watermelon, water or milk, weakening of digestion system
  9. watermelon, water or milk, fever
  10. watermelon, water or milk, cold
  11. watermelon, water or milk, cholera
  12. watermelon, water or milk, vitiligo
  13. watermelon, water, loose motion
  14. muskmelon, water or milk, weakening of digestion system
  15. muskmelon, water or milk, fever
  16. muskmelon, water or milk, cold
  17. muskmelon, water or milk, cholera
  18. muskmelon, water or milk, vitiligo
  19. muskmelon, water, loose motion
  20. corn, water or milk, weakening of digestion system
  21. corn, water or milk, fever
  22. corn, water or milk, cold
  23. corn, water or milk, cholera
  24. corn, water or milk, vitiligo
  25. corn, water, loose motion

To answer your question, someone would have to find 25 experiments (which have almost certainly never been done, because many of the claims are ludicrous but that's a separate issue. [Hint: Read about the cause of cholera.)

This is too much to ask one person to do. I would suggest "Select one claim. Show it is notable. Edit to ask just that," but that might be considered a discussion of policy which you have decried.

I would link to how to delete your account but that is a policy discussion too.

| |
  • Thanks for your response. I have edited the question. I don't have any references to justify the claim. Most of the references I had were about drinking water but the most popular myth that I have heard of is about drinkin milk after eating watermelon.I agree that the claim is ludicrous. Wikipedea says that cholera is due to "...eating foods and/or drinking water contaminated with the bacterium Vibrio Cholerae."In India most of the people are vegetarian so the main cause of cholera may be drinking contaminated stuff and people made a misbelief of drinking after eating or such.Anyhow[cont] – user31782 Sep 17 '14 at 6:27
  • [cont] since I do not have references to prove that the claim is notable so I guess the question[revised ver] also doesn't fit the rules of your website. In that case please close my question stating the appropriate reason as it is not too broad now and delete my account; I have followed the prescribed criteria. – user31782 Sep 17 '14 at 6:34
  • Seems like the policy of deleting account is different here. I haven't yet followed the prescribed guidelines. – user31782 Sep 17 '14 at 6:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .