patrick87 Contradicts himself, Is Wrong and Should Feel Bad
(Three paragraphs of nonsense.)
We are all human. Surely it is reasonable to expect patrick87 contradicted himself sometime in the past, has been wrong about something and given the suffering in the world should feel at least partly bad for the condition of his fellow man.
(Three more paragraphs on something unrelated.)
Now imagine this article has been copy-pasted a dozen times on the Internet, with the URL "http://.../patrick87_hypocrite_always_wrong_should_be_ashamed.html".
I would say that asking whether patrick87 is a hypocrite and is always wrong and should be ashamed is a valid question for the site, even though the article doesn't strictly say so - indeed, the article is completely factual, and the title is maybe only misleading.