I asked this question, and it was closed as "unclear":
Ordinarily, I would chalk this up to the general unreasonableness of people who disagree with me and move on, but someone made this comment on the question:
I'm not sure there's a clear claim to scientifically examine here (as opposed to a fairly wide field). It's a very interesting topic, but I have a feeling the question would be a better fit on a social science or psychology site.
After reading that, I have a feeling that a physics question with a similar level of detail would not have been closed. But maybe I'm unable to look at this objectively.
Do we want to hold social science to a higher standard? And regardless, was this a good closure or a bad closure?