Say a person is accused of murder.
Say we doubt he really did it.
Is that on topic?
It's notable. Definitely.
It's answerable based on evidence.
So it seems like it's a model question. It's on topic. Reasonable numbers of people is
Some answers here says it's on topic.
Not quite clear
Note: For some reason I feel it's off topic. However, I can't really figure out how. For some reason also, I feel asking if https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreyfus_affair is a traitor is on topic. I just can't really point out why. Just a hunch.