This is the question: Did Derren Brown use subliminal messages in this trick?

My question is nothing like the question it is redirecting too. That question asks for a different thing and my question asks for a different thing.

The only way I'll get a satisfactory answer is when my question is answered, the answers to that question aren't satisfying my query.

| |

Please have a read of the discussion here: Are magic tricks in scope?

Please also have a read of the answer of the duplicated question that directly addresses your question, particularly the quote from Derren Brown:

I am often dishonest in my techniques, but always honest about my dishonesty. As I say in each show, 'I mix magic, suggestion, psychology, misdirection and showmanship'. I happily admit cheating, as it's all part of the game. I hope some of the fun for the viewer comes from not knowing what's real and what isn't. I am an entertainer first and foremost, and I am careful not to cross any moral line that would take me into manipulating people's real-life decisions or belief systems.

It isn't necessary to investigate whether subliminal messages work the way Derren Brown represents them, because it is not a notable claim. because Derren Brown is a professional magician who proudly tells falsehoods for a living.

| |
  • Whether subliminal messages work(as in they are effective in changing behavior) is a valid topic for discussion on Skeptics Stack Exchange. And my question is part of this line of investigation. – noviceFedora Apr 2 at 18:46
  • Whether quantum tunnelling works is a valid topic of investigation. Whether quantum tunnelling made this coin appear from inside your ear, just because a magician told you it did, is not. – Oddthinking Apr 3 at 2:08
  • Quantum Tunneling is valid topic for Physics SE not Skeptics SE. – noviceFedora Apr 4 at 19:05
  • Your analogy fails because it is not the same, we can know in 99% of cases QT will make the coin disappear, whereas my questions subject is within realm of skeptics SE. – noviceFedora Apr 4 at 19:06
  • There should other moderators who should be involved in decided the closure of question, not just you. – noviceFedora Apr 4 at 19:07
  • 1
    I don't propose to spend any more time on this; it seems a clear case of a fictional claim being made by a talented magician who is play-acting on stage. You can edit the question to find a serious notable claim, persuade 5 regulars with enough rep to vote to reopen your existing question, and/or click on the Contact link below to discuss with StackExchange staff if you think you have not been treated fairly by any moderators. – Oddthinking Apr 4 at 19:33

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .