4

There is a picture circulating on social media of a BBC headline from 2017 about a major UK political figure with an unfortunate typo: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Es5oYlpWMAYbvLg.jpg. I want to ask whether that typo was made and quickly corrected by the BBC (or put differently, whether that picture was digitally faked). Is that on-topic?

1
  • The q is interesting, but given the fleeting nature of the evidence, I'm unsure it can be reasonably answered to Skeptics evidence standards... – Fizz Feb 2 at 21:05
4

As the help center says, Skeptics is all about challenging notable claims.

If someone came across an image of a headline like that, then there are a number of questions I could imagine a person would have:

  • Is/was this a real headline?
  • Is what the headline saying true?
  • Was this a typo, or was the wording intentional?

Any of those questions could be on-topic here, however just posting the image and asking the question isn't enough. What they'd also need is to show that people are claiming that it's a real headline, and that this claim is widely believed.

So, if you ask your question and also link (for example) a well-known person/site presenting it as true, or show that there are widely shared/viewed posts treating it as though it's true, then your question should be on-topic.

I saw that one of your other questions also asked whether the content of an image was real, and as part of that question you linked a tweet that appeared to have been widely viewed/liked/retweeted/etc. That's exactly the sort of thing that easily meets the notability requirements, so if you can find something similar for this headline then you shouldn't have any issues.

2
  • I see. twitter.com/GraystonThe/status/1355135322225577986 is the original tweet I got the image from. Does that tweet have enough likes/RTs to be considered notable? oh wait, there's also this tweet: twitter.com/ClaireHammond/status/823100058304397312 – Nzall Jan 29 at 21:45
  • @Nzall: There's no hard rule about how many likes/RTs/views/whatever is considered notable. A few dozen or hundreds is probably not enough, a couple thousand like that first tweet would probably be fine, but if it's in the 10's of thousands like that second tweet then I doubt anyone would say it's not notable. – Giter Jan 29 at 22:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .