I have a feeling that too many questions seem to be getting closed, and I can't seem to make sense of why they were closed. The standard
closed as not a real question does not really say what the problem with the question is. (It is as vague as the questions it is meant to be used for.)
Two recent examples are:
(Note: I had asked the second question.)
What I would like is for a discussion on
- Why these questions deserve to be open/closed?
- Is there any way that the closing/reopening process made more public? People stand a better chance of improving the question if they are told what the problem is.