4

I think that is to what is to .

Since we don't allow tags describing a position, shouldn't we make the [alt-medicines] tag a synonyms of the [medicine] tag? Claims about alternative medicine can be verified by the same experts that can verify claims medicine. It's the same pool of expert; it's just that one of the two tends to have a lot more false claims.

4

I disagree.

Anti-vaccination is not a shot you can take instead of a regular vaccine. Alt med is not an opinion.

The pool of expertise may have a certain overlap, but not necessarily; more importantly, there isn't obviously an overlap in the pool of interest.

In , your ideal respondent might be a doctor. If you ask "Propranolol against hypertension, is this a hoax?" a doctor might say, "Propranolol is a β-blocker, it blocks the action of epinephrine and norepinephrine, which will soothe hypertension and also tremor. Notably, Kim Jong Su from North Korea was a pistol shooter who won the Olympic Games in 2008, but was later disqualified for the use of propranolol. Incidentally, I'm not really a doctor and all of this info is from Wikipedia."

If you're talking about you might be asking something like "Can dilution really make a substance more potent?", to which our hypothetical doctor might only be able to say "I don't know. I've only studied real medicines. I really can't be bothered with all that homeopathy jazz."

Sure, alternative medicine is only medicine that hasn't been proven to work, but in our field, that's a pretty important distinction. Sure, there's an overlap of expertise, but hey, we're all skeptics here. There's an overlap of expertise between and as well.

I think the important thing here is that the two tags will probably feature very different kinds of questions. The obvious problem, of course, being that when your question is "does X work?", you wouldn't know which of the two tags to use. I'd recommend going for alt med in those circumstances, since I believe that "does X work" will be the kind of question we'll mainly be seeing in that tag anyway.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .